Player Ratings: Man City Vs Man United

𝕹𝖍𝖆𝖙𝖗𝖆𝖓𝖌 𝕿𝖊𝖈𝖍

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Dec 16, 2024

38 visitor like this post

Share

Player Ratings: Manchester City vs Manchester United - A Derby Day Deconstruction

The Manchester Derby. A clash of titans, a battle for bragging rights, and a spectacle of skill and passion. This analysis dives deep into the individual performances from the latest Manchester City vs Manchester United encounter, providing player ratings and insightful commentary. We'll dissect the key moments, highlighting both outstanding displays and areas for improvement. Let's break down the action.

Manchester City Ratings

Kevin De Bruyne (9/10): Simply unplayable. De Bruyne dictated the tempo of the game, orchestrating attacks with pinpoint passes and creating numerous chances. His vision and execution were sublime, culminating in a goal and an assist. A truly masterful performance from the Belgian maestro.

Erling Haaland (8.5/10): While not on the scoresheet this time, Haaland's presence was undeniable. His tireless pressing forced errors, and his physicality caused havoc in the United defense. He was unlucky not to find the back of the net but remains a constant threat.

Jack Grealish (8/10): A lively and energetic display from Grealish, who provided width and consistently beat his marker. His dribbling ability was a key component in City's attacking fluidity. A solid contribution to the overall team performance.

Rodri (7.5/10): A rock in midfield. Rodri's defensive contributions were crucial, shielding the backline and breaking up United's attacks effectively. His passing was accurate and controlled, maintaining City's possession dominance.

John Stones (7/10): A composed and assured performance at the heart of City's defense. Stones dealt comfortably with United's attacking threats, making timely interceptions and clearances. A reliable presence.

Others: Ruben Dias (7), Kyle Walker (7), Bernardo Silva (6.5), Ilkay Gundogan (6.5), Manuel Akanji (6.5), Ederson (6).

Manchester United Ratings

Casemiro (7.5/10): United's best player on the day. Casemiro battled tirelessly in midfield, winning tackles and providing much-needed defensive stability. His presence was a significant factor in limiting City's dominance, though ultimately it wasn't enough.

Marcus Rashford (7/10): A constant threat on the counterattack, Rashford caused problems for City's defense with his pace and direct running. He almost scored a spectacular goal, showing his individual brilliance even in a difficult match.

Bruno Fernandes (6.5/10): Showed flashes of his usual creative brilliance, but his overall impact was limited by City's strong midfield dominance. He worked hard but lacked the final killer pass.

Lisandro Martinez (6/10): Faced a difficult afternoon against City's potent attack. While committed, he struggled at times to cope with Haaland's physicality and De Bruyne's intelligent movement.

Raphael Varane (6/10): Similar to Martinez, Varane had a tough time dealing with City's relentless pressure. His passing was decent, but defensively, he was tested throughout the match.

Others: David De Gea (6.5), Aaron Wan-Bissaka (6), Luke Shaw (6), Christian Eriksen (6), Antony (5.5), Alejandro Garnacho (5.5).

Overall Analysis:

Manchester City dominated possession and created a significant number of chances, ultimately winning the match comfortably. Their midfield control, spearheaded by De Bruyne and Rodri, was instrumental in their success. Manchester United fought valiantly, particularly through the tireless efforts of Casemiro and the occasional brilliance of Rashford, but ultimately lacked the cutting edge to trouble City significantly. The difference in quality between the two squads was evident.

This match highlights the gulf in class between these two teams currently. While United showed glimpses of their potential, particularly in the counter, City were simply on another level, showcasing their superior tactical awareness, individual talent, and collective synergy. This derby underscored the need for further improvements at Manchester United to bridge the gap with their cross-city rivals.