Man City Vs Man United: Player Ratings

𝕹𝖍𝖆𝖙𝖗𝖆𝖓𝖌 𝕿𝖊𝖈𝖍

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Dec 16, 2024

38 visitor like this post

Share

Man City vs Man United: Player Ratings - A Detailed Breakdown

The Manchester Derby is always a spectacle, a clash of titans that leaves fans breathless. This year's match between Manchester City and Manchester United was no different, a thrilling encounter filled with breathtaking moments and controversial decisions. This post provides a detailed breakdown of the player ratings, analyzing individual performances and their contribution to the overall game.

Manchester City Player Ratings

Key: 5 - Poor, 6 - Below Average, 7 - Average, 8 - Good, 9 - Excellent, 10 - Exceptional

• Ederson (8): Made crucial saves when called upon, showcasing his composure and experience under pressure. His distribution was also excellent, initiating several attacks from the back.

• Kyle Walker (7.5): Solid defensively, containing United's attacks down his flank effectively. Showed his usual pace and strength, though perhaps lacked the attacking impetus we sometimes see.

• Ruben Dias (8.5): A commanding performance at the heart of City's defense. Won almost every aerial duel, made crucial interceptions, and organized the backline with his usual authority.

• John Stones (8): Partnered Dias exceptionally well. Showed his composure on the ball and his ability to read the game, contributing significantly to City's defensive solidity.

• Nathan Aké (7): Offered a balanced performance, defensively sound and contributing to City's build-up play. Could have been more adventurous going forward.

• Rodri (8): Controlled the midfield battle, shielding the defense effectively and distributing the ball with precision. His presence was vital in dictating the tempo of the game.

• Kevin De Bruyne (9): A masterclass. His vision, passing range, and creativity were on full display, creating numerous chances for his teammates and dictating the flow of the game. A true game-changer.

• Jack Grealish (7.5): Energetic and involved, making intelligent runs and contributing to City's attacking threat. His dribbling ability caused problems for United's defense.

• Bernardo Silva (8): A tireless worker, linking defense and attack seamlessly. His intelligence and technical ability were crucial in City's midfield dominance.

• Erling Haaland (9): Scored a crucial goal, showcasing his predatory instincts in front of goal. His presence alone causes havoc for opposing defenses, disrupting their structure and forcing them to react.

• Julian Álvarez (7): Came on as a substitute and made an immediate impact with his pace and energy. His contribution in the final stages of the game was valuable.

Manchester United Player Ratings

• Andre Onana (7): Made several good saves but could have done better with at least one of City's goals. His distribution was also effective.

• Aaron Wan-Bissaka (6.5): Struggled to contain Grealish and De Bruyne at times, showcasing a defensive vulnerability.

• Lisandro Martínez (7): Battled hard against City's attacking threat, winning several tackles. His passion was undeniable.

• Raphael Varane (7): A solid performance but couldn't prevent City's attacks completely. Showed his usual defensive strength and composure.

• Luke Shaw (6): Defensively challenged at times by City's attacking prowess.

• Casemiro (7): His usual combative presence in midfield, but found it difficult to contain City's dominance in the middle of the park.

• Bruno Fernandes (6.5): A frustrating game for the United captain. Showed flashes of brilliance but lacked overall consistency.

• Antony (6): Unable to make a significant impact on the game, lacking the decisiveness required against a strong City defense.

• Marcus Rashford (7): Showed glimpses of his threat, but lacked the support to make a greater impact.

• Alejandro Garnacho (6.5): Came on as a substitute and added energy to United's attack.

• Jadon Sancho (6): Struggled to assert himself against a strong City defense.

Conclusion

Manchester City's victory was deserved, reflecting their dominance in possession and clinical finishing. While Manchester United showed moments of quality, they ultimately struggled to contain City's relentless attacking prowess. The player ratings reflect the overall performance of each individual, providing a glimpse into the strategic battles and individual contributions that shaped this captivating Manchester Derby.