Man City Vs Man United: Match Player Ratings

𝕹𝖍𝖆𝖙𝖗𝖆𝖓𝖌 𝕿𝖊𝖈𝖍

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Dec 17, 2024

44 visitor like this post

Share

Man City vs Man United: Match Player Ratings – A Tactical Breakdown

The Manchester derby is always a spectacle, a clash of titans that leaves fans breathless. This year's encounter between Manchester City and Manchester United was no different, a thrilling match filled with tactical battles, individual brilliance, and ultimately, a City victory. But beyond the final scoreline, let's delve into the individual performances and assign player ratings for both teams. This analysis considers not only goals and assists but also defensive contributions, midfield control, and overall impact on the game.

Manchester City Player Ratings:

Kevin De Bruyne (9/10): The Belgian maestro orchestrated City's attack with his usual elegance and precision. His vision, passing range, and key contributions in the build-up play were simply outstanding. A masterclass performance.

Erling Haaland (8.5/10): Haaland's goalscoring prowess was on full display, though he didn't bag a hat-trick this time. His movement, power, and ability to find space in the box remain a constant threat. His physical presence also disrupted United's defensive structure.

Jack Grealish (8/10): Grealish provided a constant outlet on the left flank, showcasing his improved defensive work rate and creativity in the final third. His dribbling ability caused United's defenders significant problems.

Rodri (7.5/10): The Spanish midfield anchor was instrumental in controlling the tempo of the game. His passing accuracy and ability to shield the defense were crucial in City's dominance.

Ruben Dias (7.5/10): A rock at the back, Dias's commanding presence and crucial tackles helped keep United's attack at bay. He won almost every aerial duel and displayed calm leadership.

John Stones (7/10): Stones contributed with solid defensive work and intelligent passing from the back. His partnership with Dias provided a strong defensive foundation for City.

Kyle Walker (7/10): Walker's pace and defensive awareness were key in neutralizing United's threats down the right flank. His experience shone through in a typically robust performance.

Bernardo Silva (7/10): Silva's tireless work rate and intelligent movement created opportunities for his teammates. His contribution in both attack and defense was valuable.

İlkay Gündoğan (6.5/10): Gündoğan played a more disciplined role, supporting the midfield and contributing to City's overall control.

Nathan Aké (6.5/10): Solid defensive contribution when he came on as a substitute.

Julian Álvarez (6/10): Offered energy and pressing in the final stages but lacked a decisive impact.

Manchester United Player Ratings:

Casemiro (7/10): United's midfield general battled hard, winning tackles and offering protection to the defense. He was one of United's better performers on a tough day.

Raphael Varane (6.5/10): Varane put in a solid defensive shift but struggled at times against City's relentless attacking pressure.

Lisandro Martínez (6/10): Martinez's aggressive style was tested against City's powerful forwards. While he made some important tackles, he was often caught out of position.

Bruno Fernandes (6/10): Fernandes' creative spark was somewhat muted, finding it difficult to influence the game as he often does.

Marcus Rashford (5.5/10): Rashford lacked his usual cutting edge and struggled to create significant chances.

Aaron Wan-Bissaka (5.5/10): Wan-Bissaka's defensive work was inconsistent, and he offered little going forward.

Luke Shaw (5/10): Had a difficult game defensively, often struggling against City's wide players.

Christian Eriksen (5/10): Eriksen's usual influence on the game was limited, struggling to create opportunities against City's midfield dominance.

Antony (5/10): Offered some exciting moments but lacked the final product.

Alejandro Garnacho (6/10): Brought some much-needed energy and pace when he came on as a substitute.

Harry Maguire (N/A): Didn't feature in the match.

Conclusion:

The Manchester derby showcased the gulf in class between the two teams, with Manchester City's superior tactical execution and individual brilliance proving decisive. While Manchester United showed glimpses of resilience, they were ultimately outclassed. This detailed player rating analysis provides a more in-depth understanding of the individual contributions and tactical battles that shaped this thrilling encounter.